Episode Cast

Shannen Doherty: Prue Halliwell
Holly Marie Combs: Piper Halliwell
Alyssa Milano: Phoebe Halliwell
Brian Krause: Leo Wyatt
James Read: Victor Bennett
Paul Wittenburg: Caleb
Bob Clendenin: Ice Cream Man
Bobby Edner: Ari
Erica Mer: Freckles
Soren Fulton: Jersey
Alexa Nikolas: Little Girl
Emmalee Thompson: Young Prue
Dylan Kasch: Child
Burnadean Jones: Receptionist
Alicia Godwin: Hypnotised Girl
Jim Jenkins: Man in Lobby

Trivia

In this episode, the actor playing the Halliwell's father not only changes from Tony Dennison to James Read, but the character's last name changes from "Halliwell" (episode 1.03) to "Bennett".

This episode title is a play on words to the children's song line You scream, I scream. We all scream for ice cream.

This is the third time that actress Emmalee Thompson plays a younger version of Prue. The two previous episodes were That '70s Episode and P3 H2O.

Song Listing

"Tonight and The Rest of My Life" by Nina Gordon

"Skin" by Collective Soul